top of page

Car clinic for transmissions: Why the best transmission doesn't always win

Johannes Roth
14 hours ago
2 min read


There are many kinds of automatic transmissions, from continuously variable systems to dual-clutch transmissions. For a car manufacturer, the choice can decide whether a model succeeds or fails. It is not only about the technically best transmission. It is about the one that drivers like most. And if it differs from their expectations, you need to know how to communicate it.


The task

Our client had developed a new type of transmission. We were asked to find out how drivers experience it.


The method: a dynamic car clinic

We invited almost 30 carefully selected drivers. They had different levels of driving experience and drove cars with different transmissions themselves.

First, we talked to each of them individually. How do they experience their current transmission? What do they expect from a future one? This let us compare expectation and experience later on.

Then we hit the road. Each person drove a fixed test route: side streets, a main road, a roundabout, a motorway section and a hill. They drove it five times, each time with a different transmission. We sat next to them, observed closely and noted every spontaneous comment.

Finally, participants discussed their experiences in mini groups of four to five people. Here we explored their impressions and the social expectations attached to a transmission.

What else we explored

Which transmission do drivers associate with which brand? How does the driving experience change how they rate the car? And perhaps even the brand?


A fascinating insight

Many swore by their own transmission beforehand. Nothing else was an option for them. After the test drive, many changed their minds. For manufacturers, this means experience convinces, not announcements. The challenge is getting committed drivers to try something new at all. We explored ways to do that, too.


The result

For our client, it was not good news. The transmission was technically mature. But it did not meet important psychological needs of drivers. So it had no prospect of success.

Still, we did not have to convince anyone. Key decision-makers from the client attended the sessions live. They heard for themselves what drivers said.

The study saved our client from a costly bad investment. In the following years, competitors with similar transmission concepts failed in the market.


Why transparency matters

The best result is useless if it is not put into practice. That is why we make our methods transparent. And that is why we support our clients in workshops as they work with the insights.

Planning a car clinic or want to know how drivers experience your technology? Get in touch: research@curth-roth.de or +49 (0) 40 3600690.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page